The Problem With Asking Men to Open Up
We’ve spent years telling men to talk about their feelings. But have we considered what happens when they finally do?

We’ve spent years telling men they need to talk about their feelings.
To be vulnerable. To communicate. To stop bottling everything up. To tell us what’s going on instead of responding with the familiar, and often deeply frustrating, “I’m fine.”
And yet, there’s a question we don’t ask nearly enough.
What happens when they finally do?
What happens when a man admits he’s frightened about money? When he confesses that he’s struggling with his mental health? When he tells his partner he feels insecure, inadequate, or overwhelmed by the responsibilities he’s carrying?
What happens when the person everyone has come to depend on admits that he doesn’t feel particularly strong?
We tend to talk about men’s emotional vulnerability as though the greatest obstacle is their willingness to express it.
And certainly, for some men, learning to recognize and communicate their emotions is an important part of the work.
But vulnerability doesn’t happen in isolation.
It happens in relationships.
And sometimes, the difficulty isn’t simply that someone doesn’t know how to open up. It’s that they’ve learned, through experience, that opening up doesn’t always feel particularly safe.
The Men Who Learned to Be Fine
Many boys grow up receiving complicated messages about emotions.
They’re encouraged to be confident, independent, resilient, and capable of handling difficult situations.
They’re praised for being strong.
For not making a fuss.
For getting on with things.
And while these qualities aren’t inherently problematic, they can become restrictive when strength is understood as the absence of vulnerability.
A boy who cries may be told to toughen up.
A teenager who expresses fear may be encouraged to stop worrying and focus on solving the problem.
A young man struggling with sadness may find that the people around him are more comfortable offering practical advice than sitting with his emotional experience.
Over time, some men learn that certain emotions are acceptable to express while others are better kept private.
Anger may feel more permissible than sadness.
Frustration may feel safer than fear.
Silence may become easier than admitting uncertainty.
And eventually, these responses can become so familiar that a man may struggle to identify what he’s feeling, even when he genuinely wants to communicate it.
This doesn’t mean men are inherently less emotionally aware than women.
Nor does it mean that every man has grown up in an environment where vulnerability was discouraged.
But social expectations surrounding masculinity can influence how people learn to experience, express, and respond to their emotions.
And those expectations don’t simply disappear when someone enters an intimate relationship.
A man who has spent much of his life learning to manage distress privately may find himself in a relationship with someone who experiences emotional openness as an essential part of connection.
One partner wants to talk.
The other wants to retreat, think, or find a solution.
And before long, both may begin feeling misunderstood.
When Silence Becomes a Relationship Problem
In couples therapy, emotional withdrawal is often experienced very differently by each partner.
One person may describe their partner as emotionally unavailable.
They feel shut out, lonely, or frustrated by the absence of meaningful conversation.
They want to know what their partner is thinking.
They want reassurance that the relationship matters.
They want to feel that they’re sharing a life with someone who is emotionally present, not simply someone who happens to live in the same house.
Meanwhile, the partner who withdraws may have an entirely different experience.
They may feel overwhelmed by emotional conversations.
They may worry that whatever they say will be misunderstood.
They may believe that expressing their feelings will lead to conflict, disappointment, or another conversation in which they somehow end up getting everything wrong.
And so they say very little.
Not necessarily because they don’t care.
Sometimes because they care enormously and have no idea how to navigate the conversation without making things worse.
This is where couples can become caught in a painful relational cycle.
One partner reaches for connection through conversation.
The other experiences the conversation as pressure and withdraws.
The withdrawal intensifies the first partner’s sense of rejection.
They pursue the conversation more urgently.
And the more urgently they pursue it, the more overwhelmed the withdrawing partner becomes.
Eventually, both begin interpreting the other’s behaviour as evidence that their own needs don’t matter.
One feels abandoned.
The other feels inadequate.
And neither feels particularly understood.
Of course, this dynamic isn’t exclusive to heterosexual couples, nor are men always the withdrawing partner.
Emotional pursuit and withdrawal can happen in relationships of every configuration.
But when a man has learned that vulnerability is uncomfortable, unfamiliar, or potentially humiliating, this pattern can become especially difficult to interrupt.
Because the very thing his partner is asking him to do may be the thing he has spent much of his life learning to avoid.
We Say We Want Vulnerability. But Which Emotions Are We Prepared to Hear?
There’s an interesting contradiction in the way we sometimes approach emotional openness.
We tell our partners we want them to be honest about their feelings.
But honesty doesn’t always arrive in a form we’re comfortable receiving.
Sometimes vulnerability looks like sadness.
Sometimes it looks like fear.
Sometimes it looks like admitting that you’re struggling to cope with responsibilities everyone assumes you can manage.
And sometimes it involves expressing feelings that are difficult for the other person to hear.
A man might admit that he’s frightened about his ability to provide financially.
He might say he feels lonely in his relationship.
He might confess that he’s been experiencing anxiety, that he’s questioning his career, or that he feels overwhelmed by the expectations placed upon him.
These disclosures can challenge the roles couples have unconsciously established.
Perhaps one partner has always been the dependable one.
The person who handles problems.
The person who remains calm when everything else feels chaotic.
And perhaps the other partner has come to rely on that stability.
When the dependable person begins expressing uncertainty, the relationship may need to make room for a version of them that hasn’t always been visible.
That can be uncomfortable.
Not necessarily because their partner doesn’t care, but because vulnerability sometimes disrupts the expectations we’ve developed about who the other person is supposed to be.
There can also be moments when someone responds to a partner’s emotional disclosure with reassurance that unintentionally shuts the conversation down.
“You’ll be fine.”
“Don’t worry about it.”
“You always figure things out.”
These responses may be offered with genuine love.
But they can also communicate that the difficult feeling needs to disappear rather than be understood.
And sometimes what a person needs isn’t reassurance that everything will work out.
Sometimes they need someone to acknowledge that things feel frightening, uncertain, or overwhelming.
Without immediately trying to fix them.
Without minimizing the experience.
And without treating the disclosure as evidence that something is wrong with them.
Vulnerability Isn’t Always Comfortable
One of the misconceptions about emotional intimacy is that vulnerability should automatically bring people closer together.
Sometimes it does.
But vulnerability can also be messy, awkward, and difficult to navigate.
Someone who has spent years avoiding emotional conversations may not suddenly become articulate and emotionally insightful because their partner has encouraged them to open up.
They may struggle to find the right words.
They may become defensive.
They may express frustration before recognizing that what they’re actually experiencing is fear.
They may begin talking and then abruptly stop because the conversation feels too exposing.
And their partner may feel disappointed.
After all, they’ve been asking for emotional openness for years.
Now that it’s happening, why does it still feel so difficult?
Because learning to communicate emotions is not the same as simply deciding to communicate them.
For some people, it involves developing an entirely new relationship with their internal experiences.
Learning to notice feelings before they become overwhelming.
Learning to distinguish sadness from anger, or shame from frustration.
Learning to express vulnerability without interpreting it as weakness.
And learning that emotional conversations don’t always require an immediate solution.
This process takes time.
It also requires patience from both people.
But patience shouldn’t mean that one partner is expected to tolerate hurtful behaviour or take responsibility for the other’s emotional development.
Understanding why someone struggles with vulnerability doesn’t remove their responsibility to work on how they communicate.
And wanting a partner to be emotionally available doesn’t mean they should be expected to disclose everything before they’re ready.
Healthy emotional intimacy requires both willingness and respect.
The Fear of Becoming a Burden
There’s another experience that I think deserves more attention when we talk about men’s mental health.
The fear of becoming a burden.
For men who have internalized the belief that their value is closely connected to what they provide, accomplish, or manage, admitting emotional distress can carry a particular kind of shame.
If you’ve spent your life believing you’re supposed to be the strong one, what happens when you no longer feel strong?
If your identity has been built around being dependable, what does it mean to admit that you’re struggling?
And if the people you love rely on you, how do you tell them that you’re not sure how much longer you can keep carrying everything?
Sometimes the answer is that you don’t.
You continue working.
You continue showing up.
You continue taking care of responsibilities.
And when someone asks how you’re doing, you tell them you’re fine.
Not because you’re deliberately hiding something.
But because you may not know how to describe your experience without feeling that you’re disappointing the people who depend on you.
This is one of the reasons I think conversations about men’s mental health need to extend beyond encouraging men to speak.
We also need to examine the expectations that make speaking feel so difficult.
What happens when a man is struggling financially?
When he’s unemployed?
When he’s experiencing depression?
When he needs emotional support rather than being the person providing it?
Does he feel that his worth remains intact?
Does he believe he can be vulnerable without becoming less respected?
Does he have relationships in which he’s allowed to be uncertain, frightened, or emotionally overwhelmed?
These are important questions.
Because emotional safety isn’t created simply by telling someone that they can talk.
It’s created through repeated experiences of being heard, respected, and accepted when they do.
Emotional Safety Has to Work Both Ways
As a relational psychotherapist, I’m interested in what happens between people when vulnerability enters the relationship.
How does one partner respond when the other expresses fear?
What happens when someone admits they’re struggling?
Can both people remain curious about the other’s emotional experience, even when it differs from their own?
And perhaps most importantly, can a couple make room for difficult feelings without immediately turning them into a problem that needs to be solved?
Sometimes partners become so focused on encouraging emotional expression that they overlook the importance of how those emotions are received.
A person may finally disclose something painful, only to find that the conversation quickly shifts toward their partner’s reaction.
Perhaps their partner becomes frightened.
Perhaps they feel criticized.
Perhaps they interpret the disclosure as evidence that the relationship is failing.
And suddenly, the person who opened up finds themselves reassuring the very person they were hoping would support them.
This can happen in either direction.
It isn’t a failure unique to men or women.
It’s a relational difficulty that arises when both people are struggling to remain emotionally present while managing their own reactions.
And it can create a powerful incentive to return to silence.
If expressing vulnerability consistently results in conflict, defensiveness, or having to take care of someone else’s emotional response, withdrawal may begin to feel like the safer option.
But emotional safety doesn’t mean that every disclosure must be met with agreement.
It doesn’t mean that partners can’t feel hurt, surprised, or challenged by what they hear.
And it certainly doesn’t mean that honesty excuses cruelty.
It means developing the capacity to hear something difficult without immediately abandoning curiosity.
To ask questions before making assumptions.
To recognize that another person’s emotional experience may be different from our own without necessarily being invalid.
And to understand that being emotionally available involves more than talking.
It also involves listening.
Perhaps We Need to Change the Question
I wonder what might happen if we approached men’s emotional vulnerability a little differently.
Instead of asking, “Why won’t he talk about his feelings?” we might begin by asking, “What has he learned about expressing them?”
Instead of assuming silence means indifference, we might become curious about whether it reflects discomfort, fear, shame, or a lack of emotional language.
Instead of expecting vulnerability to arrive fully formed, we might recognize that learning to communicate emotionally can be an unfamiliar and sometimes uncomfortable process.
And instead of treating emotional openness as something one partner needs to achieve for the benefit of the other, we might begin understanding it as something couples develop together.
That doesn’t mean every experience of emotional withdrawal should be excused.
There are relationships in which one partner repeatedly refuses to engage, dismisses the other’s needs, or uses silence as a means of control.
Those experiences deserve to be taken seriously.
But there’s an important difference between someone who is unwilling to consider their partner’s emotional needs and someone who is struggling to develop skills they were never encouraged to learn.
Understanding that difference can change how couples approach the problem.
It allows us to move away from blame and toward a more meaningful exploration of what’s happening beneath the surface.
And it creates space for both partners to take responsibility for how they participate in the relationship.
Because emotional intimacy isn’t built by one person demanding vulnerability and the other reluctantly providing it.
It’s built through experiences of mutual openness, responsiveness, and trust.
What Happens When We Finally Make Room?
International Men’s Day offers an opportunity to reflect on the emotional experiences of men beyond the familiar conversations about strength, resilience, and responsibility.
It invites us to consider what happens when the expectations surrounding masculinity leave little room for uncertainty, sadness, fear, or emotional dependence.
But I think it also invites us to consider the relationships in which men are expected to express those experiences.
Because we cannot encourage vulnerability while continuing to treat it as something that diminishes a person’s worth.
We cannot ask someone to be emotionally honest and then expect their honesty to arrive only in forms that make us comfortable.
And we cannot assume that emotional connection will develop simply because someone has finally found the courage to speak.
Connection requires someone willing to listen.
Someone willing to remain curious.
Someone who can recognize that the person they love may have emotional experiences they’ve never fully understood.
Of course, that responsibility doesn’t belong to one partner alone.
Men also have a responsibility to develop emotional awareness, communicate their needs, and recognize how withdrawal or defensiveness may affect the people closest to them.
And partners deserve relationships in which their own emotional needs are acknowledged rather than continually postponed.
But perhaps the conversation needs to become less about convincing men to talk and more about understanding what makes emotional openness possible in the first place.
Because sometimes the man who says he’s fine isn’t asking to be left alone.
Sometimes he simply doesn’t know how to say anything else.
And perhaps the most meaningful response isn’t another request for him to open up.
Perhaps it’s creating the kind of relationship in which, when he eventually finds the words, he doesn’t have to wonder whether he’ll regret saying them.
⸻
Supporting Men’s Mental Health and Emotional Connection
At Psychotherapy in the City, we recognize that emotional vulnerability, relationship difficulties, anxiety, stress, and depression can affect people in different ways.
For some men, seeking therapy may be the first opportunity they’ve had to explore emotions they’ve spent years managing privately. For others, therapy offers a space to better understand patterns of withdrawal, communication difficulties, or the pressure to remain strong for everyone around them.
Our therapists work with individuals and couples to explore these experiences, develop greater emotional awareness, and strengthen the ways they communicate and connect.
Whether you’re struggling to express what you’re feeling or finding it difficult to connect emotionally with someone you love, therapy can provide an opportunity to better understand what’s happening beneath the surface.
Because emotional strength isn’t measured by how much we can carry without speaking. Sometimes it begins with allowing ourselves to be heard.




Comments